In a perfect world, Heather Ellis would seem like a source of pride for her hometown of Kennett, Mo. As a high school honor student she earned a position on the National Honor Roll and was recognized as a National Achievement Scholar while rounding out her American heartland persona as a cheerleader, a member of the Volleyball and Track teams, the Drama Club, the Spanish Club and her high school band. After graduating high school, she left Kennett, continuing her education at Maryville College and Xavier University, where she was recognized for her leadership abilities.
The problem is that this isnt a perfect world and some folks in Kennett, Mo., apparently didnt appreciate the return from college of a dignified young black woman with a sense of social justice and an expectation to be treated with dignity and respect. While on leave from college in January 2007, Heather Ellis went shopping with her cousin at the local Kennett Wal-Mart. She left in handcuffs, allegedly bleeding, after, according to prosecutors, cutting to the front of the checkout line and disturbing the peace of two white Wal-Mart employees. Now, more than two years later, shes facing trial on multiple felony counts stemming from that fateful January evening and the Ku Klux Klan has come to town.
To put this odd prosecution into context, we need to look at Kennett, located in rural Dunklin County, four miles from the Arkansas border in Missouris Boot Heel Region. Kennetts official government website boasts a six paragraph city history, devoting one of those paragraphs to the countys 1862 defection to the Confederacy. Dunklin County is adamantly conservative, with Republicans handing Mike Huckabee an almost three-to-one victory over John McCain.
Today Dunklin County is 89% white and 9% black. Sticking with Missouris history of never repealing its laws banning marriages between white folks and Asians or blacks, 88% of Dunklin Countys voters recently voted for new marriage restrictions, this time aimed at gays.
This is the Dunklin County Heather Ellis returned to from Xavier University for winter break. It was near closing time when Ellis and her cousin David got on line to check out at the Kennett Wal Mart. There were two checkout lanes open. Ellis got on one line, David on the other. When Davids line moved quicker, Ellis claims she moved over and joined him. The Kennett Police Departments arrest report states that Ellis broke in line and walked to the front of the line, to the cash register attendant, apparently because she did not want to wait in line.
At least two white customers reportedly objected to Ellis joining David on line. One, according to Ellis, pushed and verbally accosted her. An off-duty Kennett Police officer working as a Wal Mart security guard came over to the line. Ellis claims she told the cashier to go ahead and ring the upset customer out ahead of her. By Elliss account however, the cashier, after ringing the upset customer out, refused to ring Ellis out, instead proceeding to ring other customers out. The Wal Mart shift manager walked over and told Ellis to leave the store. By all accounts she refused to leave and demanded to be rung out like the other customers, hence she was charged with trespassing. Ellis subsequently wrote, I felt like I was part of the civil rights movement I thought I had traveled in a time capsule and was living in Mississippi in the 1960s. The guard radioed his fellow police officers. David telephoned his mother. Police and relatives were now en-route to the stand-off.
The police arrived and Ellis was allowed to pay for her goods. According to Ellis, however, the cashier refused to give her the change she was due. The arresting officer claims that the Wal Mart shift manager demanded Ellis be removed from the store, but that Ellis told him, Im not going nowhere until I get my f***ing change back. Ellis denies the language the arrest report attributes to her, but both she and the police are in agreement that Wal-Mart was withholding her change, with the arresting officer adding, So I stood by while the cashier attendant handed the belligerent female her change. Belligerent being the core of the peace disturbance charge.
In her statement, Ellis wrote that she was hopeful the officers would give her a little support with her demand for her change. She added that they didnt provide any, which is corroborated by the arresting officers statement that he stood by while Ellis was apparently being provoked by the Wal-Mart cashier, with her manager at her side.
Once outside of the store, according to Elliss subsequent complaint, five Kennett police officers proceeded to torment her with racist and misogynist slurs as she and David walked to their car. Ellis claims that while still walking to her car, she suggested to the police that they instead harass drug dealers and crack heads, rather than taxpaying citizens. The police report claims she refused repeated requests to calm down and was not receptive to these simple requests. As her aunt arrived by car, the officers arrested Ellis quite violently, by her account, lifting her off the ground and tossing her into a police car as her aunt helplessly stood by and watched while herself allegedly being threatened with arrest. Heathers mother arrived at the police station in time to witness what she describes as her daughter being pulled out of the car by her hair and slammed against a wall. Ellis was charged with resisting arrest and two felony counts of assaulting subsequently uninjured law enforcement officers. That was in January 2007.
The Dunklin County prosecutor dismissed charges against Ellis in early December of 2007. At this point the family thought their legal nightmare was over. One month later, shortly after New Years Day of 2008, however, the prosecutor re-filed charges and issued an arrest warrant and extradition order to take Ellis in as a wanted felon. At press time, Ellis is still facing a zealous prosecution and up to 15 years in a Missouri prison. Friends and relatives, such as her 83-year-old grandmother, claim that theyve received harassing visits from representatives of the Dunklin County Prosecutors Office fishing for dirt on Ellis. The white Wal-Mart customer Ellis accuses of pushing her was never charged. Other white customers and Wal-Mart employees are listed in police reports as the victims of Elliss peace disturbance.
Ellis and her supporting witnesses claim that she was racially targeted by Kennett Police officers who repeatedly called her a nigger and a bitch both before and during her arrest. Her narrative also indicates that three Wal-Mart employees apparently mistreated and baited her based on the fact that she was black. Ellis and her cousin David were the only black folks present, with all the Wal-Mart workers and customers, as well as the five Kennett police officers, being white. Elliss supporters argue that the zealous two-and-a-half-year prosecution of the case, accusing her of two felony assaults despite the lack of a single injured victim, is also racially motivated. They support their claim with a litany of what they argue are similar racially motivated prosecutions conducted by the Dunklin County prosecutors office over the last two decades, which they contrast with weak prosecution and light sentencing of violent white criminals during the same time period.
In June 2009, the local NAACP chapter organized a rally to protest what they argue is racist police violence directed against Heather Ellis. According to Jesse Bonner, president of the NAACP chapter, Kennett is still set in the old ways and racism is still strong down here. According to Bonner, the situation is mind boggling, with the black community in Kennett feeling as if they were back in the 1960s in the middle of the civil rights struggle.
The depth of the struggle ahead of Kennetts black residents was driven home, according to Bonner, during the rally when a Kennett police officer handed a rally organizer a Ku Klux Klan business card, then echoed the text of the card by telling her she just received a social visit from the KKK and warning her that the next visit would not be social. According to the local newspaper, The Dunklin Democrat, Kennett police were just making organizers aware that such cards had been scattered around downtown and that they were actively removing them from the streets. In essence, the official line has the police investigating Klan activity by turning over their evidence to organizers of a protest against alleged racist police misconduct. Interestingly, there are no current allegations of any Klan activity in the area that doesnt involve the Kennett Police Department.
Bonner summed up the situation in Kennett, calling it intolerable and describing an alarming tension in the air. Like Ellis, Bonner had spent considerable time away from what he describes as a racist climate in Kennett, having served nine years in the military. And like Ellis, he became accustomed to being treated with a dignity that he claims black folks in Kennett often dont experience. His response was to become active with the NAACP and the civil rights movement, which he argues, is still in the midst of a struggle at least in Kennett. Elliss response appears to be the simple demand to receive her change at Wal-Mart.
After the rally, Bonner and the NAACP ignored the supposed KKK warning and joined Elliss family and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference in calling for an FBI investigation into the Kennett Police Department and the Dunklin County Prosecutors office. The American Civil Liberties Union has also become involved, at this point observing the situation, lending support to the Ellis family and contacting the US Justice Department Civil Rights Division and the US Attorneys Office formally requesting investigations.
Wal-Mart officials have so far refused to comment on the case or clarify their role in the prosecution of Heather Ellis. They wont answer questions about the actions of their employees in the events leading up to Elliss arrest or whether or not they have conducted an investigation into allegations of possible racial bias at their Kennett store. At press time, the Dunklin County Prosecutor is still pursuing felony charges against Ellis. With the charges pending, a school district that offered Ellis a position as a teacher and track coach, withdrew its offer.
Dr. Michael I. Niman is a professor of journalism at Buffalo State College in New York. He writes for ArtVoice (Buffalos weekly), Coldtype (Canada) and The Humanist. See mediastudy.com.
From The Progressive Populist, September 1, 2009
Subscribe to The Progressive Populist